WRESTLING WITH DESTRUCTION

ILL-PREPARED: Many ruins are located on the property of municipal sites in Ayutthaya, such as Wat Prasart, which has suffered from the flooding along with the nearby hospital.

The ancient city of Ayutthaya, founded in 1350, near the site of an earlier Khmer settlement, grew into a thriving maritime city that European visitors described as the ''Venice of the East''. The old city evolved into a vital regional centre for trade, religion and refuge. 

Five dynasties and 34 kings ruled in Ayutthaya before Burmese troops destroyed the Siamese capital in 1767.

New Siamese capitals were built in Thon Buri and Bangkok, which further expedited the destruction of Ayutthaya. To fund his wars with Burma, 

King Taksin the Great sent boats to the old capital to retrieve silver from Wat Pradu Songtham and gold from Wat Phutthaisuwan. King Rama I later hauled away ships full of Buddha images and building materials. 

King Rama III then dismantled Ayutthaya's city walls and fortresses to construct Wat Saket in Bangkok, which collapsed into rubble that is now known as the Temple of the Golden Mountain. 

French missionary Jean-Baptiste Pallegoix observed at the time that there was a mania to seek treasure in the ruins of Ayutthaya.

People have continued to destroy the ancient ruins in modern times. With nationalistic fervour, in the 1950s, Field Marshal Phibun Songkhram created land codes to push Ayutthaya into becoming a modern city. 

Ancient canals were buried to make way for roads and motor vehicles. A shockingly large number of ruins were cleared away to create space for modern buildings. 

The Chao Phraya Dam, completed in Chai Nat in 1957, permanently changed irrigation practices and the local rice industry.

Also in 1957, massive city-wide looting occurred when valuable treasure was discovered in crypts at Wat Mahatat and Wat Rajaburana. 

This theft spread to the lesser-known ruins in the city as well. Ironically, Phibun's nationalistic push to modernise the country helped destroy the traditional lifestyle that comprised Thailand's heart. Locals became even more detached from this historical past, and greed took over. 

In 1964, Sumet Jumsai, the father of Thailand's architectural preservation movement, observed bulldozers flattening old chedis so that precious items could be sold, and he noted government plans to divide land in the old city to sell to private individuals. 

Because of this destruction, a small group of people became more conscious of the historic value of Ayutthaya's historic sites and attempted to protect them.

One of the first victories for the preservation of ancient sites in Ayutthaya took place in 1972. Building works ploughed up five temples near Wat Yai Chai Mongkhon for an extension of the Ayutthaya Agricultural School. 

This development was halted after students petitioned for the protection of these ruins. A second victory occurred with the passage of the Conservation of Monuments Act of 1985. 

Another victory occurred in the 1990s as squatters were pressured to finally leave slum dwellings beside Ayutthaya Historic Park. Over 60 families encroached on this protected property during the 1970s and refused to relocate for nearly 20 years.

The battle between the modern and ancient city continues to this day as the city struggles to answer questions about the value of old historic sites within a modern city of increasing population growth.

REBUILDING

A small chedi at a deserted ruin known as Wat Singharam on the main city island, and the same chedi after it collapsed due to two months of heavy flooding, above right.

The popular historic sites mentioned in guidebooks for their size and grandness will naturally receive more attention since tourists are willing to pay money to see them. 

But what will happen to the remote historical sites; many of which are scattered off the main city island and covered by heavy vegetation? Does the nation need them more than a future apartment complex or factory?

I wondered about this when I discovered that the main memorial tower of one of my favourite deserted temples, Wat Sam Jin, had collapsed into a thousand bricks. This ruin was unknown to almost everyone, and now it is gone. 

It is comforting that I had led many students to this historic site while it stood. We photographed it earlier and created a document of what it once looked like. Over time the bricks and artefacts in situ will be carried away by future floods. 

Wat Sam Jin will likely become a brick mound like dozens of others in the city. I also wondered where the bones of Portuguese settlers had floated off to and if any of them had been saved.

The value of small forgotten historic sites will be determined in the months following this flood. Budgets are being drafted and money has been earmarked to rebuild damaged roads and old architectural structures. 

Professionals have been brought in to determine if the ruins are safe enough for tourists to return. At this point, people seem shell-shocked and are still at the stage of gathering information. 

Damage has apparently shown in the main prang-style chedi at Wat Phra Ram, and a large crack has appeared on the shins of the popular reclining Buddha image at Wat Lokaysutharam. 

How these sites will be restored is still a matter of discussion. Most of this cultural heritage is protected by legislation, but it will take much more work to protect these sites from future floods.

I have contacted members of the Fine Arts Department, Unesco and the International Council on Monuments and Sites. 

I have also discussed the damage with leading historians and academics. However, my role is primarily that of a teacher. 

I can only show representatives of these organisations how to find these forgotten historic sites and perhaps instil pride in my students by involving them in repair work.

One student told me not to worry so much about countryside ruins. He reminded me of the Buddhist belief that nothing is permanent. 

Time must pass for everything, including sites of cultural heritage. It's true - nothing is permanent, but hopefully, one day, neither will apathy be.

NATURE TAKES ITS COURSE

Flooding widened cracks at this small deserted ruin, which is all that remains of a former Buddhist temple known as Wat Mongkut north of the main city island. It now may topple over.

As the water level ate its way up to my second floor dwelling in mid-October, I realised that this flood would cause massive damage throughout the city. 

I had no electricity or plumbing and water seeped through the cracks of my wooden floor. Poisonous snakes sought shelter in my house. Many students were trapped at home and could no longer come to class. A significant number of locals died. 

For a while, I tried to deliver emergency supplies via kayak to people in more remote areas and to check on the situation at lesser known historic sites in the city (some of which had been completely engulfed by water). I realised that it was time to leave when my kayak got stuck on the roof of someone's house.

During the flood, I was able to kayak down paved roads that had once been ancient canals. I could not help but think that modernisation had exacerbated the damage. The ancient city had been designed in response to the inevitable seasonal flooding. 

Locals dug canals for transport and to move excessive water toward areas where it could be stored for times of drought. These arteries were frequently dredged as people used them daily by boat.

The city walls helped to protect residents from rising flood levels. Houses were built on stilts high above the ground. The ancient temples were raised on mounds, and people could seek refuge in them during times of floods.

In contrast, the modern city is not set up to survive large-scale flooding. Many canals are blocked or landlocked by dirt bridges and paved roads. 

Other canals have filled with hyacinth and plastic bags full of rubbish _ neither of which existed in the ancient city. 

Old reservoirs were filled in to create new neighbourhoods, and nearly all traces of the city walls have been toppled. 

New homes are often constructed at ground level, and few locals own boats any more. As a result, the damage is more severe than in the past.

Historic sites are further eroded by monsoonal winds and tropical storms. Rain and humidity seep into holes dug by looters. Vegetation growth widens cracks in architecture, causing bricks to split in two and plaster to fall off walls. 

The ruins gradually shift balance as they sink in mud due to their weight. Maintenance of these historic sites is time-consuming and expensive.

Nevertheless, residents of the modern city often survived floods by seeking refuge at ancient sites. Many set up shelters on the higher ground of crumbled mounds that formerly functioned as temples. Animals huddled on the dilapidated foundations of ruins. 

Long abandoned sermon halls (viharn) hosted families and their belongings. For these people, the value of these deserted ruins is unquestionable.

THE VALUE OF CURIOSITY

A classroom at Phranakhon Si Ayutthaya Rajabhat University. The university plans to tear down the building due to severe damage.

As a teacher at Phranakhon Si Ayutthaya Rajabhat University specialising in tourism studies, I have asked students these questions many times.

In order to pique their interest, I set out to track down and explore the remains of the ancient city. These were the numerous "forgotten" ruins; there are so many historic sites in Ayutthaya that the smaller and less significant ones barely attract attention. I had no idea how difficult this goal would be. 

These deserted ruins hide at modern schools, police stations, hospitals, residential areas and overgrown jungles. The present municipality of Ayutthaya has sprouted from the damaged roots of the old capital. 

The old and the new have merged in such a way that they can't be separated. By the time my research was completed, three years had passed.

In the process of seeking out deserted ruins in the countryside, I was bitten by stray dogs, struck at by poisonous snakes, stung by countless insects and hospitalised for a month after major spinal surgery after a speeding motorcycle hit me. 

In the end, I tracked down and photographed nearly 500 historic sites (active temples, abandoned ruins, foreign settlements, bridges, gates, etc), which I hoped to share with students in the classroom.

Unfortunately, my photos of historic sites didn't arouse their curiosity. They cared about active temples with Buddhist clergy; not the deserted ruins that they considered full of ghosts.

But the students knew I was curious, so they offered assistance and learned in the process of gathering information.

They volunteered to go to these places with me and help translate.

As they engaged elderly Thais about these hidden sites, they became more active and involved. Some students would bring into class old books, 

maps and photographs that their grandparents had lent them to share with other students. Class became more informal and based around the exchange of dialogue instead of textbooks. 

I started to post this new information on various websites and later helped create www.ayutthaya-history.com so that this material could be preserved and accessible to future generations. As a result, my teaching grew into a type of community development.

Ayutthaya's 'forgotten' temples damned by deluge Lesser-known historic sites in the ancient capital were severely damaged by the floods and now that reconstruction has begun they may be forever abandoned in favour of more prominent spots

WATERY GRAVE: Left, dozens of skeletons were found at the site of a Portuguese settlement in Ayutthaya in the 1970s. Right, the burial pit as it looks now after waters inundated the area.

Walking down splintered side roads in post-flood Ayutthaya recently - among the rotting debris of rubbish mountains, animal carcasses and rusted motor vehicles - I sensed that the aftermath would be harsh. 

Homes had been destroyed. Large trees had been ripped up by their roots. Many parts of the city still remained beneath water after two to three months of flooding. 

My task was to seek out small deserted ruins (wat raeng) and countryside temples (wat rad), ones that few locals and tourists have ever heard of, so that I could survey the damage.

This personal research was the saddest academic activity I have ever undertaken. Flooding caused at least one large ruin to collapse into a mound of bricks, fresh cracks split the walls and foundations of other structures, 

and a centuries-old Portuguese graveyard displaying dozens of skeletons had been transformed into a swimming pool. I realised that some of these historic sites could never be repaired. 

Ultimately, the questions are raised: What is the value of these lesser known, non-revenue generating, ancient historic structures in a modern city that is rapidly urbanising? What importance will they have for future Thai generations?

Political suspects 'deserve better'

The Truth for Reconciliation Commission is standing firm on its recommendation that people charged with political offences, including red shirt co-leader Arisman Pongruangrong, be detained separately from other inmates.

TRC chairman Kanit na Nakorn said those involved in last year's unrest were driven by political motivations and did not deserve to be lumped in with criminals.

Such a separation would help forge improved relations between state authorities and red shirt suspects.

The TRC made the recommendation in September. Mr Arisman surrendered to authorities last week.

"Our recommendation is based on academic principles without any prejudice and favour," Mr Kanit said.

Democrat Party leader Abhisit Vejjajiva has opposed a move by the Corrections Department to send Mr Arisman and other red shirt suspects to a detention centre for political prisoners at the former Bang Khen private police school in Lak Si district.

Mr Abhisit said he would not object if those who were charged with violating the emergency decree for their role in rallies were separated from other inmates.

But terrorism, assault, illegal use of war weapons and arson attacks were criminal violations, not political offences, he said.

Earlier, Corrections Department chief Suchart Wong-ananchai said the relocation of Mr Arisman and other political suspects to the new detention facility was in line with suggestions by the TRC, which is investigating clashes between the red shirts and security forces in April and May last year.

Mr Arisman was charged with instigating an insurrection against the Abhisit government after turning himself in to the Department of Special Investigation on Wednesday.

Sophon Thitithamphruek, director of Bangkok Remand Prison, said Mr Arisman appeared stressed after two days in detention. But he was complying with the rules and the regulations of the prison, 

Mr Sophon said, adding that fellow inmates had been assigned to take care of Mr Arisman, who previously said he was being hunted down.

A cell fit for a fugitive

The political prisoner detention centre at the old Bang Khen police private school is not luxurious and it did not get a makeover in advance of the arrival of high-profile red shirts, said the Corrections Department chief.

In fact, the facility is no different from the detention cell at a police station, department chief Suchart Wong-ananchai told the Bangkok Post Sunday.

"We did not decorate the facility to accommodate any VIPs," he said.

The department was responding to suggestions that the facility was being spruced up to receive high-profile political prisoners, including key red shirts.

A large number of red shirts currently detained at Khlong Prem Prison will be relocated to the centre on Dec 21.

It was widely believed the facility was being modernised in anticipation of ousted premier Thaksin Shinawatra's return from exile abroad to face a two-year jail term handed down by the Supreme Court in the Ratchadaphisek land case. It was thought he might spend time at the centre while seeking amnesty.

Red shirt leader Arisman Pongruangrong, currently detained in Khlong Prem on a charge of instigating an insurrection against the previous government, may also be brought to the centre.

Pol Col Suchart dismissed reports the centre was an air-conditioned VIP facility. "What we did was improve the interior by painting the bars in the cells in beige to make it feel more airy," he said.

The cells are similar in size to those at police stations, about 20 square metres.

In the past, the school housed political prisoners and those charged with communism-related offences. They were detained separately from criminal suspects.

Pol Col Suchart said no cell at the centre is air-conditioned. Each cell is equipped with a toilet but it's not a luxury commode _ the toilets have no doors. A one-metre wall partially obscures it from view.

Eurozone deal lacks 'firepower'

VIENNA: A summit deal struck by all EU countries except Britain lacks the necessary "firepower" to tackle the underlying causes of the eurozone crisis, Austrian Chancellor Werner Faymann said Saturday.

"A firewall was created, but it is not strong or large enough to have a big deterrent effect on speculators and the financial markets in the coming years," Faymann told the Salzburger Nachrichten daily in an interview.

"The decisions taken lack the necessary firepower to have a sustained effect."

Prime Minister David Cameron said Britain will not be excluded from the European Union for opting out of a treaty aimed at saving the euro, but its relationship with the bloc has changed.

"We are not being excluded, we are in the European Union, we're a leading member of the single market," Cameron told British broadcasters after a summit in Brussels.

"When it comes to defence, we're the leading (EU) member of NATO, when it comes to driving forward European foreign policy, we're actually one of the leading players in that.

"But no we're not in the single currency, we don't want to be in the single currency, we're not in the Schengen no-borders agreement and I'm glad we're not in that."

Cameron blocked an EU-wide treaty on tighter budget policing overnight, saying that it would have threatened Britain's vital financial services sector in the City of London.

But afterwards the other 26 members of the EU said they were willing to join a "new fiscal compact" to resolve the two-year euro debt crisis, leaving Britain in the cold in Europe.

"In terms of the future, yes of course this does represent a change in our relationship with Europe," Cameron said.

"But the core of our relationship -- the single market, the trade, the investment, the growth, the jobs that we want to see -- that remains as it was."

Austria's Fayman said that the agreement made in Brussels on Friday on tighter budget discipline was a "large step on the path towards more independence from financial markets and (sovereign bond) creditors."

But he added: "What is missing are financial market regulations, a European rating agency (and) European revenues from financial markets through a tax on financial transactions."

The summit ended with 26 of the 27 member states signalling their willingness to join a "new fiscal compact" after Britain vetoed having tough new budget rules enshrined in a modified EU treaty, as pushed by Germany and France.

Faymann said that British Prime Minister David Cameron's negotiating tactics at the summit "were in blatant contradiction to the spirit, and the team spirit, of the European Union."

The pact, due to be finalised in March, includes plans to impose near-automatic sanctions on countries running excessive deficits and gives Brussels greater powers overseeing national budgets.

Leaders hope the pact will convince the European Central Bank to drop its reluctance to use its full arsenal against the crisis, with the Frankfurt institution seen as the beleaguered eurozone's best hope.

The 17 eurozone countries signed up to the pact while nine other non-euro EU nations "indicated the possibility to take part in this process" after consulting their parliaments, EU leaders said in a statement.

Hungary had originally voiced reluctance, while Sweden and the Czech Republic were undecided.

Five seats likely to go in reshuffle PHEU THAI HONCHOS MEET THAKSIN FOR TALKS

A major cabinet shakeup involving at least five ministerial posts is expected to come out of a meeting this weekend between leading Pheu Thai figures and ousted prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra in Singapore.

Some will survive, some will not, as Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra and Big Brother Thaksin mull who should go, who should stay in a cabinet reshuffle early next year.

The changes, likely to come into effect in the New Year, will result in seat-swapping and in the dropping of ministers deemed to have underperformed, a Pheu Thai Party source said. 


The reshuffle is aimed at bolstering the Yingluck Shinawatra cabinet in the face of heavy criticism, especially pertaining to its handling of the flood crisis.

Speculation about the reshuffle was sparked yesterday as former Thai Rak Thai executives and Pheu Thai MPs flew to Singapore to meet Thaksin.

Thaksin's sister, Yaowapa Wongsawat, and former Thai Rak Thai executive Warathep Ratanakorn arrived in Singapore a day earlier, the source said.

Deputy Prime Minister Chalerm Yubamrung has confirmed a reshuffle is due after the New Year.

Mr Chalerm was among the first to meet Thaksin. They also met last month in China.

The source said Thaksin has given the green light to the shake-up, which is aimed at shoring up the government's image and credibility.

Justice Minister Pracha Promnok, who was grilled in a censure debate last month over his handling of the flood crisis as director of the Flood Relief Operations Command, is said to be among those at risk of losing his position. 

This list reportedly also includes Social Development and Human Security Minister Santi Prompat, Education Minister Woravat Au-apinyakul, PM's Office Minister Krissana Seehalak and Agriculture and Cooperatives Minister Theera Wongsamut.

Deputy Prime Minister Yongyuth Wichaidit, who is also the interior minister, may lose that portfolio, said the source.

Prime Minister Yingluck yesterday denied any knowledge of a possible ouster of Mr Theera, a Chartthaipattana minister, saying the government is busy with post-flood rehabilitation efforts.

"We are working together to tackle the persistent floods and to prepare rehabilitation [for flooded areas]. This is the government's priority," she said.

Mr Theera declined to comment, saying the authority to order a reshuffle rests with the prime minister.

He has been accused of poor water management by protecting Suphan Buri from the flood at the expense of other central provinces and parts of Bangkok.

Chartthaipattana spokesman Watchara Kannikar said there is no indication of a reshuffle from the core coalition party.

His party is confident its ministers are up to the task and should not be dropped from the line-up.

Pongthep Thepkanchana, one of the 111 former Thai Rak Thai executives suspended for five years and due to return to politics next year, said the Yingluck government needs to make changes if certain cabinet ministers are not up to the job.

Otherwise, the government's popularity will be diminished and it will be vulnerable to attempts to overthrow it, he said.

Mr Pongthep noted that the government will have more "players" to choose from when the 111 suspended politicians complete their political ban in May.

He also urged the government to proceed with care when dealing with any issues that might be linked to Thaksin or the monarchy, as some groups politicise them.

Some say Thaksin has approached the Bhumjaithai party to join the cabinet and replace Chartthaipattana.

However, the overture did not seem to interest Bhumjaithai de-facto leader Newin Chidchob.

Meanwhile, there has also been a reported attempt to lure seven MPs under Somsak Thepsuthin's Wang Nam Yom faction away from Bhumjaithai.

Three MPs in the faction abstained from voting in the no-confidence censure against Mr Pracha.

However, the group is thought to be unlikely to defect.